Determining gridiron greatness is a task fraught with peril, especially when spanning an entire century of college football. The debate rages on: who truly stands above the rest? Bill Connelly of ESPN recently tackled this challenge, compiling a list of the 25 best college football players of the 21st century, a selection sure to spark conversation and disagreement. This ranking serves as a testament to the remarkable talent that has graced college football fields in recent decades.
The Top Tier: Defining Excellence
Connelly’s list is a who’s who of college football legends. The number one spot is claimed by Ndamukong Suh, the dominant defensive tackle from Nebraska. Suh’s impact on the game was undeniable, a force that disrupted offenses and struck fear into opposing quarterbacks. Following closely behind at number two is Baker Mayfield, the charismatic and prolific quarterback from Oklahoma. Mayfield’s leadership and playmaking ability made him a Heisman Trophy winner and a fan favorite.
Rounding out the top three is Cam Newton, the Auburn quarterback whose electrifying 2010 season led the Tigers to a national championship. Newton’s combination of size, speed, and arm strength made him a unique and unstoppable force. Vince Young, the Texas quarterback who led the Longhorns to a memorable Rose Bowl victory over USC, sits at number four. Young’s performance in that game cemented his place in college football history.
Legends in the Making
The top ten is further populated by iconic players who left an indelible mark on the sport. Ed Reed, the ball-hawking safety from Miami, is recognized for his exceptional instincts and playmaking ability. Tim Tebow, the Florida quarterback known for his passion and leadership, also makes the list. Reggie Bush, the electrifying USC running back, is included, though his legacy remains complex due to subsequent controversies. Bryan McKinnie of Miami, Joe Burrow of LSU, and Larry Fitzgerald of Pittsburgh round out the top ten, each representing a unique blend of talent and achievement.
SEC Dominance and Notable Omissions
The Southeastern Conference (SEC) is well-represented throughout the list, reflecting the conference’s sustained success on the national stage. Two Alabama legends, wide receiver DeVonta Smith at No. 19 and outside linebacker Will Anderson Jr. at No. 22, further solidify the SEC’s presence. Smith, known for his incredible hands and route-running ability, played a crucial role in Alabama’s championship runs. Anderson, a dominant pass rusher, terrorized opposing quarterbacks and anchored the Crimson Tide defense.
Connelly acknowledges the inherent difficulty in creating such a list, noting that many players could arguably be ranked higher. He also points out that at least 50 other players could easily be included, highlighting the depth of talent in college football over the past two decades. This underscores the subjective nature of such rankings and the endless debates they inevitably spark.
The Debate Continues: Lasting Impact
Ultimately, any list of the best college football players is bound to be controversial. Fans will passionately argue for their favorite players and debate the merits of different eras and positions. The true measure of a player’s greatness often lies in their impact on the game, their ability to inspire teammates, and the memories they create for fans. While rankings provide a framework for discussion, the legacy of these players extends far beyond any numerical designation.
Bill Connelly’s compilation for ESPN serves as a valuable contribution to this ongoing discussion. By highlighting the achievements of these 25 players, he reminds us of the incredible talent and passion that define college football. While disagreements are inevitable, the list provides a starting point for celebrating the legends of the 21st century.
